What is debt consolidation, and when is it worth it?
How one loan replaces several balances, what it can and cannot fix, and the sums to do before you decide.
The short version
- Consolidation replaces several debts with one loan and one monthly payment.
- It saves money only if the new loan costs less in total than the debts it pays off.
- It changes how you repay. It does not reduce what you owe.
If you are paying three or four cards every month, each with its own due date and rate, you already know how much attention that takes. Debt consolidation is one way to simplify it. This guide explains how it works, when it helps, and when it is better left alone.
How debt consolidation works
You take out one new loan and use it to pay off the balances you choose. Those accounts drop to zero, and from then on you make a single payment to a single lender.
With a personal loan, that payment is usually fixed. The rate does not move, the amount is the same every month, and you know the date of the final payment on the day you sign. A credit card works differently: the minimum payment shrinks as the balance does, which is why card debt can last for many years.
What you can consolidate
Most people consolidate unsecured debts, meaning debts with nothing pledged against them:
- Credit cards and store cards
- Medical bills
- Other personal loans
Which debts are eligible depends on the lender and the loan agreement. Mortgages and car loans are secured against the home or the car and are normally handled separately.
Before and after, side by side
| Several card balances | One consolidation loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Payments each month | One for every account | One |
| Interest rate | Often variable, different on each card | Usually fixed for the whole term |
| Payment amount | Changes with the balance | The same every month |
| End date | Open-ended | Set when you sign |
When it is worth it
Consolidation tends to work well when three things are true.
- The new loan costs less. Compare APR, not just the interest rate, because APR includes the lender’s fees.
- The payment fits your budget. A fixed payment is only helpful if you can make it comfortably every month.
- The cards stay paid off. The loan clears the balances; it does not close the accounts. New spending on them is new debt on top of the loan.
When it is not
Leave it alone if the rate you are offered is no better than what you pay today, or if fees cancel out the saving. It is also a poor fit when the balances are small enough to clear within a few months anyway.
If the payments are already unmanageable, a new loan may not be the answer. A nonprofit credit counsellor can go through your options with you, often at no charge.
How to compare an offer
Before you accept any consolidation loan, write down four numbers for it and for your current debts:
- The APR
- Any fees, including an origination fee taken from the loan amount
- The monthly payment
- The total you will repay by the end of the term
If the loan wins on total cost and the payment is one you can keep up, it is doing its job. Our consolidation calculator shows the monthly payment for different amounts and terms.
Common questions
Does consolidating hurt my credit?
A full loan application usually involves a hard credit inquiry, which can lower a score slightly for a while. What matters more over time is paying on schedule and keeping card balances low.
Will I definitely save money?
No. Savings depend on the rate, fees and term you are offered compared with what you pay now. Work out the total repayment on both sides before deciding.
Is consolidation the same as debt settlement?
No. With consolidation you repay everything you owe on new terms. Settlement means negotiating with creditors to accept less than the full balance, which carries different costs and a heavier effect on credit.
Should I close my cards afterwards?
That is your choice. Keeping an account open with a zero balance can help your credit utilisation; closing it removes the temptation to spend. Choose whichever makes it easier to stay out of new debt.
